American Idol's Class of 2006 reunion brought Kellie Pickler back to the stage and delivered nearly a dozen fine performances from the five finalists. Just three singers remain after Monday night's (May 4) episode.

With the Top 3 now decided, here is who is left on America's most popular singing reality show.

  • Luke Bryan, Carrie Underwood and Lionel Richie returned as judges for Season 24 of American Idol.
  • New episodes air on Monday nights at 8PM ET on ABC.
  • Jamal Roberts won Season 23 of American Idol.

READ MOREEvery American Idol Winner Ranked, Least to Most Memorable

Each of the five finalists performed twice. The first performance was a solo performance with Dancing With the Stars celebrities working in the background.

The second found each singer paired with a Season 5 American Idol finalist. Taylor Hicks was the biggest name to return but country fans were dying to hear from Pickler, who's been mostly absent from stages and the spotlight since the 2023 death of her husband.

She didn't disappoint.

Here is a full list of finalist performances:

Keyla Richardson: Ike and Tina Turner, “River Deep - Mountain Hight”
Chris Tungseth: Noah Kahan, “Northern Attitude”
Braden Rumfelt: Teddy Swims, “Lose Control”
Hannah Harper: Peggy Lee, “Fever”
Jordan McCullough: Leona Lewis, “Footprints In the Sand”
Keyla Richardson and Taylor Hicks: Stevie Wonder, “Living for the City”
Chris Tungseth and Bucky Covington: Garth Brooks, “The Thunder Rolls”
Braden Rumfelt and Paris Jackson: Queen, “The Show Must Go On”
Hannah Harper and Kellie Pickler: Martina McBride, “Broken Wing”
Jordan McCullough and Elliott Yamin: “A Song for You”

Kellie Pickler Returns To American Idol?

Pickler's return to Idol was full circle as she sang one of the two songs she used to audition, Martina McBride's "Broken Wing." Harper took lead but Pickler's part's carried extra weight with all she's been through. The crowd and three judges (including Paula Abdul!) loved it.

McCullough's cover of Leona Lewis was also tremendous as was Richardson's two performances. The panel continued to ask for more from Braden Rumfelt while the admired the power and comfort of Chris Tungseth.

As always, America voted in the end.

Eric McCandless, Disney Via Getty Images
Eric McCandless, Disney Via Getty Images
loading...

Who Went Home on American Idol?

Monday's (May 4) episode of American Idol sent two singers home: Braden Rumfelt and Chris Tungseth.

The result was perhaps a bit predictable as McCullough, Hannah Harper and Richardson have emerged as favorites in this competition. Expect a star-studded finale next Monday (May 11).

American Idol Season 24 Schedule:

April 13 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Week
April 20 Disney Night
April 27 Taylor Swift Songs
May 4 American Idol 20th Anniversary Reunion
May 11 Finale

Who's Left on American Idol?

A full list of who is still competing on American Idol appears below. This list will be updated after each elimination round of American Idol.

Remaining 'American Idol' Contestants: Season 24

Who's left on American Idol, Season 24? Here are the Top 3 contestants left ahead of the May 11, 2026 finale on ABC.

Gallery Credit: Billy Dukes

Every 'American Idol' Winner Ranked: Least To Most Memorable

Be honest, do you remember who won American Idol last year? He's at No. 16 on this list of American Idol winners, ranked least to most memorable.

We've sorted each of the show's 23 champions in order of who is most famous to country fans. No. 1 may be predictable but a thorough scroll may trigger voting memories from seasons past, plus an update on who is still active in music today.

Gallery Credit: Billy Dukes

More From Gator 99.5